The Carnivore Diet has been popularized recently and it makes certain claims about it’s benefits for human nutrition. This article is designed to examine some of those claims. Let’s look at some of the positives and negatives of the diet.
Let’s start with the definition:
- According to Healthline, “The Carnivore Diet consists entirely of meat and animal products.”
The diet consists of eating meat for all meals. I think of it as The Keto Diet on steroids.
Let’s look at some of it’s claims and research that may support the diet:
- The Carnivore Diet promotes weight loss:
This has been the case in just about every instance that I have witnessed. According to Healthline’s article, All You Need to Know About The Carnivore Diet, “High protein diets can help you feel fuller for a longer period which may lead to lower calorie intake.” Simply said, you will eat less, causing you to lose weight. I can see why people have lose weight and become advocates of this diet.
- It claims that all plant foods are toxic:
This is the claim that plant foods have natural defense mechanisms called lectins that can precipitate inflammation and disease. Lectins have recently gotten more exposure in the nutrition world. “Lectins can also bind to cells linerary and digestive tracts which may disrupt the breakdown and absorption of nutrients and affect the growth and action of the intestinal flora,” according to The Nutrition Source, Harvard’s T.H Chan. Advocates of The Carnivore Diet claim that the diet is gut friendly.
- The Carnivore Diet will lower cases of type 2 diabetes:
There is no secret that type 2 diabetes is an issue in the western world. The standard western diet is too high in sugar and refined carbohydrates. The constant insulin spike can lead to type 2 diabetes. Is The Carnivore Diet the solution? Researchers are studying the effects of high protein, high fat and low carb diet on diabetes. Studies on Pubmed indicate that a high protein, high fat and low carb diet can improve insulin insensitivity. On its face, it seems to be a possible solution to a serious underlying health issue.
Things to be concerned with if you are on the Carnivore Diet:
- Vitamin & Mineral Deficiency:
A diet that excludes plant life may lack necessary vitamins and minerals.
- Protein and Uric Acid Overload:
According to Dr. Christopher Labos, cardiologist at McGill’s Office for Science and Society, “eating such a high amount of animal meat, may increase your level of uric acid and may cause Gout.” There is a study done in The New England Journal of Medicine that shows that higher levels of meat and seafood are associated with increased risk of Gout. A high meat diet may put more pressure on and damage your kidneys.
- High Blood Pressure:
Simply put, eating a lot of salted meat, mainly red meat may raise your blood pressure. Have a discussion with your doctor or dietitian if you struggle to maintain a healthy blood pressure.
- Cholesterol:
This has become a controversial topic. Traditional medicine tells us that there are 2 types of cholesterol, HDL (good cholesterol) and LDL(bad cholesterol) . Traditionally, the goal is to increase your HDL and decrease your LDL. Advocates of The Carnivore Diet will say that cholesterol is not bad for you. Some even say that it is ok if your LDL cholesterol increases.
I say it is better to err on the side of caution. Consult your doctor if you struggle to maintain a healthy level of cholesterol.
- Long-Term Effects:
There isn’t enough long term scientific evidence of the effects of a diet that solely relies on animal meat.
Should you follow the Carnivore Diet?
This is a loaded question. It really depends on who you ask. I sustain a gut friendly, high protein, high fat, low carb diet. We do not have enough information to determine if it is best to sustain a pure meat diet.
If you determine to follow The Carnivore Diet :
- Have a serious discussion with your doctor or dietitian
- Consider the pros and the cons, even beyond what is mentioned in this article.
- Opt for less processed, higher quality and grass finished meat